Performance and sustainability of the makhana (Euryale ferox Salisbury) cum fish culture system in India

Shailendra Raut; Kamal Sarma; Indu Shekhar  Singh; Jaspreet Singh; Vinod Kumar  Padala; Surendra Kumar Ahirwal; Tarkeshwar Kumar; Ravi Kumar; Bakul Ranjan  Jana; Bhagwati Prasad Bhatt

doi:10.21077/ijf.2025.72.2.147354-10

Authors

Shailendra Raut ICAR-National Research Centre for Makhana, Darbhanga- 846005, Bihar, India
Kamal Sarma ICAR Research Complex for Eastern Region, Patna-800014, Bihar, India
Indu Shekhar Singh ICAR-National Research Centre for Makhana, Darbhanga- 846005, Bihar, India
Jaspreet Singh ICAR Research Complex for Eastern Region, Patna-800014, Bihar, India
Vinod Kumar Padala ICAR-National Research Centre for Makhana, Darbhanga- 846005, Bihar, India
Surendra Kumar Ahirwal ICAR Research Complex for Eastern Region, Patna-800014, Bihar, India
Tarkeshwar Kumar ICAR Research Complex for Eastern Region, Patna-800014, Bihar, India
Ravi Kumar ICAR-Mahatma Gandhi Integrated Farming Research Institute (MGIFRI), Piprakothi- 845429, Motihari, East Champaran, Bihar, India
Bakul Ranjan Jana ICAR-National Research Centre for Makhana, Darbhanga- 846005, Bihar, India
Bhagwati Prasad Bhatt Natural Resource Management Division, Krishi Anusandhan Bhawan-II, Pusa, New Delhi 110 012, India

https://doi.org/10.21077/ijf.2025.72.2.147354-10

Keywords:

Makhana , Fish integration, Plankton, Proximate composition, Economic analysis

Abstract

Makhana (Euryale ferox Salisbury) is a commercial aquatic crop cultivated in the small waterlogged areas of north Bihar, India. Given the importance of Makhana, the present study was designed to evaluate the performance and economic feasibility of semi-intensive integrated makhana cum fish farming. In the current investigation, two treatments were evaluated: sole makhana cultivation (T1) and integrated makhana-fish culture (T2). Both treatments were conducted in triplicate across four different locations in Bihar, India. In treatment T2, fingerlings of catla (Catla catla), rohu (Labeo rohita), mrigal (Cirrhinus mrigala), bata (Labeo bata), Kawai (Anabas testudineus) and snakehead (Channa striatus) were stocked at a ratio of 3:2:2:1:1:1, respectively (6000 no. ha-1). The result revealed that only makhana cultivation (T1) yielded 1.78±0.133 t ha-1 seed, whereas 1.55±0.085 t ha-1 seed and 1.48±0.15 t ha-1 fish were produced under an integrated makhana-fish culture system (T2). Net benefits from T1 and T2 were `1,78,820±18633.40 and `2,74,007.89±83648, respectively. The estimated input cost, returns, and revenue in the experiment significantly differed among the treatments, as assessed by the Wilcoxon-Mann-Whitney test (p<0.05) (Wilcoxon, 1945). In T2, individual catla and rohu had an average weight of 574.82±31.54 and 624.55±11.5 g, respectively, which resulted in a total biomass of 0.74±0.070 t ha-1 and 0.57±0.087 t ha-1, respectively. The biomass of catla and rohu was higher than the other stocked fish species and they were compatible with makhana cultivation in an integrated aquaculture system. The estimated concentration of biotic and abiotic parameters in each treatment was the optimum level pertaining to productivity. In addition, these semi-intensive technologies could help generate a surplus income of over 50% compared to traditional makhana cultivation methods and are more nutritionally sustainable than the monoculture method.

Keywords: Economic analysis, Fish integration, Makhana, Plankton, Proximate composition

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Adkar, P., Dongare, A., Ambavade, S. and Bhaskar, V. H., 2014. Trapa bispinosa Roxb.: a review on nutritional and pharmacological aspects. Adv. Pharmacol. Sci., 2014: 13. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1155/2014/959830

Ahmed, M. U., Alam, M. I., Debnath, S., Debrot, A. O., Rahman, M. M., Ahsan, M. N. and Verdegem, M. C. J. 2023. The impact of mangroves in small-holder shrimp ponds in south-west Bangladesh on productivity and economic and environmental resilience. Aquaculture, 571. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aquaculture.2023.739464

AOAC. 2005. Official method of Analysis. 18th Edition, Association of Officiating Analytical Chemists, Washington DC.

APHA. 2005. Standard methods for the examination of water and waste-water. 21st Ed. American Public Health Association, Washington, DC.

Alvarez-Garcia, M., Urrestarazu, M., Guil-Guerrero, J. L. and Jimenez-Becker, S. 2019. Effect of fertigation using fish production wastewater on Pelargonium x zonale growth and nutrient content. Agric. Water. Manag., 223: 105726. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.agwat.2019.105726

Arthur, J. R., Lavilla-Pitogo, C. R. and Subasinghe, R. P. 2000. Use of Chemicals in Aquaculture in Asia, Southeast Asian Fisheries Development Center Aquaculture Department Tigbauan, Iloilo, Philippines, pp 144.

Ayyappan, S., Moza, U., Gopalkrishan, A., Meenakumari, B., Jena, J.K. and Pandey A. K. 2011. Handbook of Fisheries and Aquaculture, Second Edition, Directorate of Knowledge Management in Agriculture, ICAR, New Delhi.

Bangar, S. P., Dunno, K., Kumar, M., Mostafa, H. and Maqsood, S. 2022. A comprehensive review on lotus seeds (Nelumbo nucifera Gaertn.): Nutritional composition, health-related bioactive properties, and industrial applications. J. Funct. Foods., 89: 104937. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jff.2022.104937

Bayulut, E. 1989. Aquaculture systems and practices: a selected review. Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. Rome.

Bhattacharjya, B. K., Choudhury, M. and Sugunan, V. V. 2003. Icthyofaunistic resources of Assam with a note on their sustainable utilization. Participatory approach for fish biodiversity conservation in Northeast India. NBFGR, Lucknow, 87–105.

Bhateria, R. and Jain, D. 2016. Water quality assessment of lake water: a review. Sustain. Water Resour. Manag., 2: 161-173. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s40899-015-0014-7

Billard, R. 1999. The carp: biology and culture. Springer -Verlag Berlin Heidelberg New York.

Edwards, P. 1980. Food potential of aquatic macrophytes. ICLARM Studies and Review 5. International Center for Living Aquatic Resources Management, Manila, Philippines 51 pp.

Dana, S. S., Ghosh, A. and Kumar, R. 2018. Factors Influencing Adoption of Scientific Technologies Related to Makhana (Euryale ferox)-Cum-Fish Culture in Bihar. Indian J. Ext. Educ., 54: 13-17.

Das, S., Der, P., Raychaudhary, U., Maulike, N. and Das, D. K. 2006. The effect of Euryale ferox Salisb. (Makhana), an herb of aquatic origin on myocardial ischemic repurfsion injury. Mol. Cell. Biochem., 289: 55-63. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11010-006-9147-1

Dehadrai, P. V. 1972. Annual report of the project coordinator and a general examination of the overall progress of work of the project. In second workshop on all Indian Coordinated research project on air breathing fishing for culture in swamp, Patna, Dec. 20-21, 5.

Dey, S., Botta, S., Kallam, R., Angadala, R. and Andugala, J. 2021. Seasonal variation in water quality parameters of Gudlavalleru Engineering College pond. Curr. Res. Green Sustain., 4: 100058. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.crgsc.2021.100058

Fathibi, K., Aneesh, E. M. and Sudhikumar, A.V. 2017. Indian fresh water zooplankton: a review. Int. J. Recent. Sci. Res., 8: 20999-21015.

Francis, T., Ramnathan, N., Athithan, S., Bhuvaneswari, K., Padmavathy, P. and Rani, P. R. D. 2004. Nutrient status of sediment from integrated fish farming systems. Indian J. Fish., 51(2): 153-160.

Funge-Smith, S. and Phillips M. J. 2001. Aquaculture systems and species. Technical Proceedings of the Conference on Aquaculture in the Third Millennium, NACA, Bangkok, Thailand, 129-135.

Gopalan, C., Sastri, R. B. V., Balasubramaniam, S. C., Narasinga Rao, B. S., Deosthale, Y. G. and Pant, K. C. 1996. Nutritive value of Indian foods. Hyderabad, India: National Institute of Nutrition, Indian Council for Medical Research.

Horppila, J. and Nurminen, L. 2003. Effects of submerged macrophytes on sediment resuspension and internal phosphorus loading in Lake Hiidenvesi (southern Finland). Water. Res., 37(18): 4468-4474. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0043-1354(03)00405-6

Jana, B. R. and Md, I. 2018. Anti-aging amino acids in Euryale ferox (Salisb.). Adv. Plants Agric. Res., 8: 43-48. DOI: https://doi.org/10.15406/apar.2018.08.00289

Jana, B. R., Bhatt, B. P., Singh, I. S. and Idris, M. 2019. A study on commercial cultivation and storage of water chestnut (Trapa natans L.) under wetland ecosystem of North Bihar, India. J. Appl. Nat. Sci., 11(2): 528-533. DOI: https://doi.org/10.31018/jans.v11i2.2105

Jha, V., Shalini, R., Kumari, A., Jha, P. and Sah, N. K. 2018. Aquacultural, nutritional and therapeutic biology of delicious seeds of Euryale ferox Salisb.: A mini review. Curr. Pharm. Biotechnol., 19(7): 545-555. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2174/1389201019666180808160058

Jhingran, A. G. 1992. Recent advances in reservoir fisheries management in India. In Reservoir Fisheries of Asia, Proceedings of the 2nd Asian Reservoir Fisheries Workshop; IDRC-Ottawa: Ontario, OA, Canada.

Chandra, K., Gopi, K., Rao, D., Valarmathi, K. and Alfred, J. 2017. Current Status of Freshwater Faunal Diversity in India: 1-624 (Published by the Director, Zool. Surv. India, Kolkata)

Kabir, K. A., Verdegem, M. C., Verreth, J. A., Phillips, M. J. and Schrama, J. W. 2020. Effect of dietary carbohydrate to lipid ratio on performance of Nile tilapia and enhancement of natural food in pond aquaculture. Aquac. Res., 51(5): 1942-1954. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/are.14546

Kumar, A. 2015. Freshwater plankton and macrophytes of India. Daya Publishing House. Delhi, 110002.

Kumar, A., Singh, I. S., Thakur, A. K., Choudhary, A. K., Jha, V., Singh, S. P., Prasad, S. S., Yadav, P. and Kumar, R. 2017. Bioaccumulation of Plant Nutrients by Euryale ferox Salisb. Growing in Field Condition in Northern Bihar of North India. Int. J. Curr. Microbiol. App. Sci., 6(7): 1229-1237. DOI: https://doi.org/10.20546/ijcmas.2017.607.148

Kumar, J., Kumar, S., Kumar, A. and Kumar S. 2019. Field performance of popping machine for Makhana seeds. Int. J. Chem. Stud., 6: 773-777.

Kumar, L., Gupta, V. K., Jha, B. K., Singh, I. S., Bhatt, B. P. and Singh, A. K. 2011. Status of Makhana (Euryale ferox Salisb.) cultivation in India. Technical Bulletin no. R32/PAT21. ICAR RCER, Patna, India.

Kumar, M., Raut, S. M., Bhatt, B.P. and Kumar, L. 2020. Scientific cultivation of Makhana for Improving Farmers’ Livelihood in Eastern India. Biotica. Research. Today., 2(7): 670-672.

Kumar, S., Sahdeo, A. and Guleria, S. 2013. Bihar floods: 2007 (A Field Report), first ed. National Institute of Disaster Management, Ministry of Home Affairs, New Delhi, India.

Larsson, B. 1994. Three overviews on Environment and Aquaculture in the Tropics and Sub-tropics. FAO, Harare, Zimbabwe, ALCOM Field Document No. 27.

Luo, J. 2013. Phytoplankton–zooplankton dynamics in periodic environments taking into account eutrophication. Math. Biosci., 245(2): 126-136. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.mbs.2013.06.002

Masram, P., Patel, K. S., Kori, V. K. and Rajgopala, S. 2015. Makhana (Euryale ferox Salisb.) A Review. Int. J. Ayu. Pharm. Chem., 4: 70.

Mishra, R. K., Vidyanath, J. and Dehadrai, P. V. 2003. Makhana. Indian Council of Agricultural Research. New Delhi, India.

Mittal, R., Sharma, S. and Mittal, A. 2020. A Critical Review on Ethnobotanical and Pharmacological Aspects of Euryale Ferox Salisb. Pharmacogn. J., 12(6): 1444-1454. DOI: https://doi.org/10.5530/pj.2020.12.199

Nazir, S., Khan, N., Azmat, H., Naveed, S., Ramzan, M. M. and Davies, S. J. 2023. Efficacy of various concentrations of synthetic hormones on the induced breeding of Channa marulius (Sole). J. World Aquac. Soc., 54(1): 143-155. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/jwas.12908

Oddsson, G. V. 2020. A definition of aquaculture intensity based on production functions-The aquaculture production intensity scale (APIS). Water, 12(3): 765. DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/w12030765

Olsen, S. R., Cole, C.V., Watanabe, F. S. and Dean. L. A. 1954. Estimation of available phosphorus in soils by extraction with NaHCO3, USDA Cir.939. U.S. Washington.

Pavlov, D. S. and Kasumyan, A. O. 2002. Feeding diversity in fishes: trophic classification of fish. J. Ichthyol., 42(2): 137-159.

Paul, B. N., Adhikari, S. and Mandal, R. N. 2017. Training Manual on Application and Practices of Fish Feed in Aquaculture, ICAR-CIFA, RRC, Rahara, Kolkata, West Bengal, India. pp:1-130

Petr, T. 2000. Interactions between fish and aquatic macrophytes in inland waters. A review. FAO Fisheries Technical Paper. No. 396. Rome, FAO. 2000, 185.

Dang, P. D., Khoi, N. V., Le Nga, T. N., Thanh, D.N. and Hai, H. T. 2015. Identification Handbook of Freshwater Zooplankton of the Mekong River and its Tributaries, Mekong River Commission, Vientiane. 207pp.

Pramanik, B. R., Puste, A. M., Jana, K., Banerjee, K., Das, D. K. and Dasgupta, M. 2013. Makhana (Euryale ferox Salisb.)-cum-fish culture: An integrated management for better yield. Bangladesh. J. Sci. Ind. Res., 48(4): 281-286. DOI: https://doi.org/10.3329/bjsir.v48i4.11501

Raut, S. M., Gupta, N., Everard, M. and Singh, I. S. 2020. Commercially and medicinally significant aquatic macrophytes: potential for improving livelihood security of indigenous communities in northern Bihar, India. J. Threat. Taxa.,12(13): 16819-16830. DOI: https://doi.org/10.11609/jott.5640.12.13.16819-16830

Reynolds, C. S., 2006. The ecology of phytoplankton. Cambridge University Press. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511542145

Sarkar, U. K. and Borah, B. C. 2018. Flood plain wetland fisheries of India: with special reference to impact of climate change. Wetlands. Ecol. Manage., 26(1): 1-15. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11273-017-9559-6

Singh, I. S., Kumar, M., Raut, S. M., Thakur, A. K. and Singh, S. P. 2020. Integrated Nutrient Management packaged for field cultivation of Makhana in North Bihar. J. AgriSearch., 7(3): 138-141. DOI: https://doi.org/10.21921/jas.v7i03.18687

Singh, I. S., Kumar, L., Bhatt, B. P., Thakur, A. K., Chaudhary, A. K. and Kumar, A. 2017. Integrated Aquaculture with Fox Nut- A Case Study from North Bihar, India. Int. J. Curr. Microbiol. App. Sci., 6 (10): 4906-4912. DOI: https://doi.org/10.20546/ijcmas.2017.610.461

Subbiah, B. V. and Asija, G. L. 1956. A Rapid Procedure for the Estimation of Available Nitrogen in Soils. Curr. Sci., 25: 259-260.

Sugunan, V. V. and Sinha, M. 2001. Sustainable capture and culture based fisheries in fresh waters of India. In: Pandian TJ (ed) Sustainable Indian fisheries. National Academy of Agricultural Sciences, New Delhi, 43–70.

Verma, A. M., Jha, V. and Ahmad, S. H. 2008. Fish-Makhana (Euryale ferox Salisb.) integration- a case study of sustainable aquafarming system in North Bihar. J. Indian Fish. Assoc., 35: 87-98.

Verma, A. M., Ahmad, S. H. and Jha, V. 1996. Integrated culture of air breathing carnivorous fishes with Makhana (Euryale ferox Salisb.) in a derelict wetland of North Bihar, India. J. Freshwater Biol., 8(2): 117-120.

Walkley, A. and Black, I. A. 1934. An Examination of the Degtjareff Method for Determining Soil Organic Matter and a Proposed Modification of the Chromic Acid Titration Method. Soil Science, 37: 29-38. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1097/00010694-193401000-00003

Wilcoxon, F., 1945. Individual Comparisons by Ranking Methods. Biom. Bull., 1(6): 80-83. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/3001968

Zhao, J., Liu, C., Li, H., Liu, J., Jiang, T., Yan, D., Tong, J. and Dong, L. 2022. Review on Ecological Response of Aquatic Plants to Balanced Harvesting. Sustainability., 14(19): 12451 DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su141912451