Optimum plot size for oil palm (Elaeis guineensis Jacq.) field experiments
OPTIMUM PLOT SIZE FOR OIL PALM FIELD EXPERIMENTS
105 / 1
Keywords:
CV, Maximum curvature, Mean square error, Oil palm, Optimum plot sizeAbstract
For standardization of water and nutrient requirements of oil palm field experimentation is essential. In order to get accurate results from the field experimentation, optimal plot size is very important. Not much work has been done on these lines to find out the optimum size of the plot for field experimentation in oil palm. In the present study, two statistical methods were employed and compared to find out the optimal plot size for conducting field experiments in oil palm under Indian conditions using 6 years yield data from ICAR-Indian Institute of Oil palm Research. Oil palm yield is measured in FFBs (fresh fruit bunches) and the FFB number and yield data of individual palms was collected from 10 different cross combinations having three replications and 270 palms. Two statistical procedures were employed on these data viz., Mean Square Error (MSE) and Maximum curvature method. From both these methods, 7 palms per plot were found to be the optimum size in oil palm for field experiments. As both MSE and maximum curvature of coefficient of variation methods have given same result, if secondary data is available for any other tree crops, one of these two methods can be employed for finding out the optimum plot size.
Downloads
References
Barreto H J and Raun W R 1990. La precision experimental de los ensayos regionales con maiz (Zea mays L.) a traves de centroamerica. In Programa regional de maiz para Centro America, Panama yEl Caribe. CIMMYT, Mexico D.F., 06600.
Bowman D T 2001. Common use of the CV: A statistical aberration in crop performance trials. The Journal of Cotton Science, 5: 137-141.
Kalidas P, Chander Rao S and Prabhakar Rao K J 2014. Indian oil palm: past, present and future scenarios. Journal of Oilseeds Research, 31(1): 1-12.
Murphy D J 2014. The future of oil palm as a major global crop: Opportunities and challenges. Journal of Oil palm Research, 26 (1), 1-24.
Peiris T S G and Thattil R O 1997. Alternative methods to determine plot sizes for tree crops: a case study from coconut data. Cocos, 12: 44-53. DOI: https://doi.org/10.4038/cocos.v12i0.2165
Polson D E 1964. Estimation of optimum size, shape, and replicate number of safflower plots for yield trials. Thesis submitted to Utah State University.
Saste S V and Sananse S L 2015. Soil heterogeneity to determine size and shape of plots: A review. International Journal of Advanced Science and Technology Research, 5(6): 201-206.