Randomized Response Techniques: Its Development in Six Decades
149 / 116
Keywords:
Crosswise model; Complex survey; Direct response; Forced RR Model; Maximum likelihood; Multiple randomized response, Non randomized response; Parallel model; Triangular Model; Primary protection.Abstract
Randomized response techniques (RR) are used to collect data relating to sensitive, personal, and /or stigmatizing characteristics. The direct method
(DR) of interview cannot be applied in such situations because the respondents generally do not reveal the true information due to the social stigma
and /or fear. So, the respondents often provide socially approved or untrue responses. As a result, DR suffers from inaccurate data and a high rate of
nonresponse. To overcome such difficulties, Warner (1965) introduced an ingenious method of data collection, known as the randomized response
(RR) technique, where respondents need not provide the true response but only to provide the outcome of a random experiment. Respondents’
privacy is maintained, as the interviewer will not identify whether the submitted response is true or masked. A chronological development of the RR
techniques for the last six decades is provided, starting with the pioneering RR model provided by Warner. Detailed developments of the RR models
for the qualitative and quantitative characteristics are provided along with the applications for the complex survey designs. Methods of estimation
of the population characteristics from the multiple randomized response techniques are presented. The methods of estimations of the proportions
of overlaps of multiple characteristics are presented. The optional randomized response techniques (ORT) are also discussed. Finally, some of the
nonrandomized response techniques (NRR) and the measures of privacy protection are presented.
Downloads
References
1. Abernathy, J.R., Greenberg, B.G., and Horvitz, D.G. (1970). Estimates
2. of induced abortion in urban North Carolina. Demography, 7,
3. 19-29.
4. Abul-Ela, A.L.A., Greenberg, B.D. and Horvitz, D.G. (1967). Multi
5. proportions randomized response model. Journal of the American
6. Statistical Association, 62, 990-1008.
7. Anderson, H. (1975). Efficiency versus protection in RR designs for
8. estimating proportions, Technical Report 9, University of Lund,
9. Sweden
10. Arnab, R. (1990). On commutativity of design and model expectations
11. in randomized response surveys. Communications in Statistics e
12. Theory and Methods, 19, 3751-3757.
13. Arnab, R. (1996). Randomized response trials: A unified approach
14. for qualitative data. Communications in Statistics - Theory and
15. Methods, 25(6), 1173-1183.
16. Arnab, R. (2004). Optional randomized response techniques for
17. complex survey designs. Biometrical Journal, 46, 1, 114-124
18. Arnab, R. (2017). Survey Sampling Theory and Applications, Academic
19. Press, U.K.
20. Arnab, R. (2021). Randomized Response Trial using Geometric
21. Distribution. Journal of the Indian Society of Agricultural
22. Statistics,75, 195–204.
23. Arnab, R. (2023). Dalenius and Vitale randomized response technique
24. for complex survey designs. Communications in Statistics-Theory
25. and Methods, 52, 684-692.
26. Arnab, R. (2025). Indirect methods of data collection and analysis.
27. Singapore, Springer.
28. Arnab, R. and Olaomi, J.O. (2019). Optional randomized response
29. technique for quantitative characteristics. Communications in
30. Statistics-Theory and Methods, 48, 4154-4170.
31. Arnab, R. and Shangodoyin, D.K. (2015). Randomized response
32. technique using maximum likelihood estimator. Communications
33. in Statistics-Theory and Methods, 44, 3340-3349.
34. Arnab, R., and Rueda, M. (2016). Optional randomized response:
35. A critical review. In vol. 34 of Hand Book of Statistics, ed. A.
36. Chaudhuri, T.C. Christofieds and C.R.Rao, 253-71. Oxford, U.K.,
37. Elsevier.
38. Arnab, R., and Shangodoyin, D.K., and Arcos, A. (2019).
39. Nonrandomized response model for complex survey designs.
40. Statistics in Transitions, 20, 67
41. Arnab, R., Shangodoyin, D.K. and Dwivedi, V.K. (2016).
42. Generalization of Randomized Response Techniques for Complex
43. Survey Designs. Journal of the Indian Society of Agricultural
44. Statistics,70, 131-138.
45. Arnab, R., Shangodoyin, D.K. and Kgosi, P.M. (2017). Randomized
46. Response Techniques with Multiple Responses. Journal of the
47. Indian Society of Agricultural Statistics, 71, 201-205.
48. Barabesi, L., Franceschi, S., Marcheselli, M. (2012). A randomized
49. response procedure for multiple sensitive attributes. Statistical
50. Papers, 53, 703-718.
51. Bhargava, M. and Singh, R. (1999). On relative efficiency of certain
52. randomized response strategies. Journal of the Indian Society of
53. the Agricultural Statistics, 52, 245-253.
54. Bhargava, M. and Singh, R. (2000). A modified randomization device
55. for Warner’s model. Statistica Anno LX(2), 315-321.
56. Bhargava, M. and Singh, R. (2002). On the efficiency comparison of
57. certain randomized response strategies. Metrika, 55, 191-197.
58. Boruach, R.F. (1972). Relations among statistical methods for assuring
59. confidentiality of social research. Communications in Statistics e
60. Theory and Methods, 19, 3751-3757.
61. Bourch, R. (1971). Assuring Confidentiality of Responses in Social
62. Research: A Note on Strategies. The American Sociologist, 6,308-411.
63. Burke, P.D. (1981). On the analysis of some multivariate randomized
64. response designs for categorical data. Journal of Statistical
65. Planning and Inference, 5, 165-170.
66. Burke, P.D. (1982). Randomized response multivariate designs for
67. categorical data. Communications in Statistics-Theory and
68. Methods, 11, 2889-2901.
69. Burke, P.D. (1990). Estimating a distribution for each category of
70. sensitive variate. Communications in Statistics-Theory and
71. Methods, 19, 3233-3241.
72. Chang, H.-J. and Liang, D.-H. (1996). A two-stage unrelated randomized
73. response procedure. Australian Journal of Statistics, 38, 43-58.
74. Chang, H.-J., Wang, C.-L., and Huang, K.-C. (2004). On estimating the
75. proportion of a qualitative sensitive character using randomized
76. response sampling. Quality and Quantity, 38, 675-680.
77. Chaudhuri, A. and Dihidar, K. (2009). Estimating means of stigmatizing
78. qualitative and quantitative variables from discretionary responses
79. randomized or direct. Sankhyā, Volume 71-B, 123-136
80. Chaudhuri, A. and Mukerjee, R. (1988). Randomized response: Theory
81. and Techniques. Marcel Dekker, New York.
82. Chaudhuri, A. and Saha, A. (2005). Optional versus compulsory
83. randomized response techniques in complex surveys. Journal of
84. the statistical planning and inference, 135, 516-527.
85. Chaudhuri, A., and Christofides , T.C. (2013). Indirect Questioning in
86. Sample surveys. Berlin, Springer
87. Christofied, T.C. (2015). A new version of the item count technique.
88. Model Assisted Statistics and Applications, 10, 289-297.
89. Cobo, B., Rueda, M., and Torrecillas, F. (2016). Application of
90. randomized response techniques for investigating cannabis use
91. by Spanish university students. International Journal of Methods
92. in Psychiatric Research, DOI: 10.1002/mpr.1517
93. Dalton, D. R. & Metzger, M. (1992). Integrity testing for personal
94. selections: An unsparing perspective. Journal of Business Ethics,
95. 12, 147-156.
96. Dihidar, K. (2016). Estimating sensitive population proportion by
97. generating randomized response following direct and inverse
98. hypergeometric distribution. Hand book of Statistics -34,
99. Chaudhuri, A ., Christofides, T.C. and Rao, C.R., 443-469.
100. Drane, W. (1976). On theory of randomized responses of two sensitive
101. questions. Communications in Statistics-Theory and Methods, 5,
102. 565-575.
103. Duffy, C.J., and Waterton, J.J. (1984). RR models for estimating the
104. distribution function of a quantitative character. International
105. Statistical Review, 52, 165-171
106. Eichorn, B.H., and Hayre, L.S. (1983). Scrambled randomized response
107. method for obtaining sensitive quantitative data. Journal of
108. Statistical Planning and Inference, 7, 307-316.
109. Eriksson, S.A. (1973). A new model for randomized response.
110. International Statistical Review, 41, 101-113
111. Flinger, M.A., Policello, G.E. and Singh, J. (1977). A comparison
112. of two RR survey methods with consideration for the level of
113. respondent protection, Communications in Statistics-Theory and
114. Methods. 6, 1511-1524.
115. Folsom, R.E., Greenberg, B.G., Horvitz, D.G., and Abernathy. J.R.
116. (1973). The two alternative questions randomized response
117. model for human surveys. Journal of the American Statistical
118. Association, 68, 525-530.
119. Fox, J. A. and Tracy, P.E. (1986). Randomized response: A method for
120. sensitive surveys. London, Sage.
121. Franklin, L.A. (1989). A comparison of estimators for randomized
122. response sampling with continuous distribution from a
123. dichotomous population. Communications in Statistics-Theory
124. and Methods, 18, 489-505.
125. Franklin, L.A. (1989a). A comparison of estimators for randomized
126. response sampling with continuous distribution from dichotomous
127. populations. Communications in Statistics-Theory and Methods,
128. 18, 489-505.
129. Geurts, M.D. (1980). Using a randomized response research design to
130. determine non-response. Journal of the Academy of Marketing
131. Science, 8, 83-90.
132. Gjestvang, C.R. and Singh, S. (2009). An improved randomized
133. response model: estimation of mean. Journal of Applied Statistics,
134. 36, 1361-1367.
135. Goodstadt, M. and Gruson, V. (1975). The Randomized Response
136. Technique: A Test of Drug Use. Journal of the American
137. Statistical Association, 70, 814-818
138. Greenberg, B. G., Kuebler, R.R., Abernathy J.R. and Horvitz, D.G.
139. (1971). Application of the randomized 21 response technique in
140. obtaining quantitative data. Journal of the American Statistical
141. Association. 66, 243-250.
142. Greenberg, B.D., Abul-Ela, A.L.A., Simmons, W.R., Horvitz, D.G.
143. (1989). The unrelated question randomized response model:
144. Theoretical framework. Journal of the American Statistical
145. Association, 64, 520-539
146. Greenberg, B.G., Abul-Ela, A.L.A., Simmons, W.R., Horvitz, D.G.
147. (1969). The unrelated question randomized response model:
148. Theoretical framework. Journal of the American Statistical
149. Association, 64, 520-539.
150. Gupta, S., Gupta, B., Singh, S. (2002). Estimation of sensitivity level
151. of personal interview survey question. Journal of Statistical
152. Planning and Inference , 100, 239-247
153. Horvitz, D. G., Greenberg, B.G. and Aber Abernathy, J.R. (1976). RR:
154. a data gathering device for sensitive questions. International
155. Statistical Review, 44, 181-196.
156. Horvitz, D. G., Shah, B. V., & Simmons, W. R. (1967). The U- question
157. randomized response model. In Proceedings of the survey
158. research methods section of the American Statistical Association
159. (pp. 65- 72).
160. Hsieh, S-H., Lee, S-M. and Tu, S-H. (2018). Randomized response
161. technique for a multilevel attribute using a single sensitive
162. question. Statistical Papers, 59, 291-306.
163. Huang, K.C., (2008). Estimation of sensitive characteristics using
164. optional randomized technique, Qual. Quant., 42, 679 - 686
165. Huang, K.C., (2010). Unbiased estimators of mean, variance and
166. sensitivity level for quantitative characteristics in finite population
167. sampling. Metrika, 71, 341-352.
168. Hubbard, M.L., Casper, R. A., and Lessler, J.T. (1989). Respondents
169. OCO reactions to item count lists and randomized response. In
170. Proceedings of Survey Research Section, American Statistical
171. Association, Washington D.C. 544OCo448.
172. Hussain, Z., Shabbir, J., Al-zahrani, B., and Khan, M. (2014). On
173. using negative binomial distribution as a randomization device
174. Raghunath Arnab / Journal of the Indian Society of Agricultural Statistics 187–206
175. in sensitive surveys. Communications in Statistics-Simulation and
176. Computation, 45, 3584-3596.
177. Hussain, Z., Shabbir, J., Pervez, Z. Shah, S.F. and Khan, M. (2017).
178. Generalized geometric distribution of order k: A flexible choice
179. to randomized response. Communications in Statistics-Simulation
180. and Computation, 46, 4708-4721.
181. 205
182. Pal, S. (2008). Unbiasedly estimating the total of a stigmatizing
183. variables from a complex survey on permitting options for direct
184. or randomized responses. Statistical papers, 49, 157-164.
185. Pollock, K.H., and Bek, Y. (1976). A comparison of three RR models for
186. quantitative data. Journal of the American Statistical Association,
187. 71, 884-886.
188. Jayraj, A. Sedory, S.A., Singh, S. and Odumade, O. (2018). A new
189. estimator of proportion with a linear function using data from
190. two-decks randomized response model. Communications in
191. Statistics- Theory and Methods, 38, 439-446
192. Kalucha, G., Gupta, S., Dass, B. K. (2015). Ratio estimation of finite
193. population mean using optional randomized response models.
194. Journal of Statistical Theory and practice, 9, 633–645.
195. Kim, J.I. and Flueck, J.A. (1978). An additive randomized response
196. model. In: Proceedings of Social Statistics section, American
197. Statistical Association, 351-355.
198. Kuk, A. Y. C. (1990). Asking sensitive question indirectly. Biometrika,
199. 77, 436-438.
200. Lanke, J. (1975). On the choice of unrelated questions in Simmons’
201. version of RR. Journal of the American Statistical Association,
202. 68, 525-530
203. Lara, D., Strickler, J., D´iaz olavarrieta, C., Ellertson, C. (2004).
204. Measuring induced abortion in mexico a comparison of four
205. methodologies, Sociological methods & research, 32(4), 529-558
206. DOI 10.1177/0049124103262685
207. Lee, C., Sedory, S.A., Singh, S. (2013). Estimating at least seven
208. measures of qualitative variables from a single sample using
209. randomized response technique. Statistical probability letters, 83,
210. 399-409.
211. Leysieffer, R.W., and Warne, S.L. (1976). Respondent jeopardy and
212. optimal designs in RR models Journal of the American Statistical
213. Association, 71, 649-656.
214. Mangat, N. S., and Singh, R. (1990). An alternative randomized
215. response procedure. Biometrika, 77, 349- 442.
216. Mangat, N.S. (1994). An improved Randomized response strategy.
217. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series B, 56, 93-95.
218. Mangat, N.S., Singh, R. and Singh, S. (1992). An improved U- question
219. randomized response strategies. Calcutta Statistical Association
220. Bulletin, 42, 277-281.
221. Mielecka-Kubień, Z. and Toniszewski, M. Estimation of illicit drug use
222. among high school students in the Silesian voivodship (Poland)
223. with the use of the randomized response technique. Mathematical
224. population studies, 29(2), 47–57, https://doi.org/10.1080/088984
225. 80.2021.1893009
226. Mieth, L., Mayer, M., Hoffmann A., Buchner, A., and Bell, R. (2021).
227. Do they really wash their hands? Prevalence estimates for
228. personal hygiene behaviour during the COVID-19 pandemic
229. based on indirect questions. Mieth et al. BMC Public Health,
230. 21(12). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-020- 10109-5
231. Moshagen, M. and Musch, J. (2012). Surveying multiple sensitive
232. attributes using extension of randomized response technique.
233. International Journal of Public Opinion research, 24, 508-523.
234. Odumade, O., and Singh, S. (2009). Efficient use of two deck of cards
235. in randomized response sampling. Communications in Statistics -
236. Theory and Methods, 38, 439-446
237. Poole, W.K. (1974). Estimation of the distribution function for a
238. continuous type random variable through RR. Journal of the
239. American Statistical Association, 69,1002-1005.
240. Quatember, A. (2009). A standardization of randomized response
241. strategies. Survey Methodology, 35,143- 152.
242. Quatember, A. (2012). An extension of the standardized randomization
243. technique to a multi-stage setup.
244. Statistical Methods and
245. Applications, 21, 475-484.
246. Rueda, M., Perri, P.F., and Cobo, B. (2018). Advances in estimating by
247. the item sum technique using auxiliary information in complex
248. surveys. AStA Advances in Statistical Analysis 102, 455-478.
249. Singh, J. (1976). A note on RR techniques. In Proceedings of the survey
250. research methods section of the American Statistical Association
251. (p. 772).
252. Singh, J. (1978). A note on maximum likelihood estimation from
253. randomized response models. In Proceedings of the survey
254. research methods section of the American Statistical Association
255. (pp. 282- 283).
256. Singh, S. (1993). An alternative to Warner’s randomized response
257. technique. Statistica, anno LIII, 67-71.
258. Singh, S. and Joarder, A.H. (1997). Unknown repeated trials in
259. randomized response sampling. Journal of the Indian Society of
260. Agricultural Statistics, 50, 70-74.
261. Singh, S. and Sedory, S.A. (2013). A new randomization device for
262. sensitive characteristics: an application to negative hypergeometric
263. distribution. Metron, 71, 3-8.
264. Singh, S. and Singh, R. (1992). Improved Franklin’s model for
265. randomized response sampling. Journal of the Indian Society of
266. Agricultural Statistics, 30, 109-122.
267. Singh, S. and Singh, R. (1993). Generalized Franklin’s model for
268. randomized response sampling. Communications in Statistics -Theory and Methods, 22, 741-755.
269. Singh, S., and Grewal, I. (2013). Geometric distribution as randomization
270. device: Implemented to the Kuk’s model. International journal of
271. contemporary Mathematical Sciences, 8, 243-248.
272. Singh, S., Horn, H., Singh, R. and Mangat, N.S. (2003). On the use of
273. modified randomization device for estimating the prevalence of
274. the sensitive attribute. Statistics in Transition, 6, 515-522.
275. Srivastava, R., Nigam, A.K., and Singh, N. (2015). Application of
276. Randomized Response Techniques in Estimation of prevalence
277. of Child Sexual Abuse. Statistics and Applications {ISSN 2454-
278. 7395(online)}
279. Su, S., Sedory, S.A. and Singh, S. (2015). Kuk’s model adjusted for
280. protection and efficiency. Sociological Methods and Research,
281. 44, 534-551.
282. Swensson, B. (1974). Combined questions: a new survey technique for
283. eliminating evasive answer bias (I). basic theory. Report No. 70 of
284. errors in survey research project, Institute of Statistics, University
285. of Stockholm.
286. 206
287. Raghunath Arnab / Journal of the Indian Society of Agricultural Statistics 187–206
288. Takahasi, K. and Sakasegawa, H. (1977). A randomized response
289. technique without making use of randomizing device. Annals of
290. the Institute of Statistical Mathematics, 29,1-8.
291. Tian, G.-L. (2014). A new non-randomized response model: The
292. parallel model. Statistica Neerlandica, 68, 294- 323.
293. Tian, M.T., Tian, G.L., Tang, M.L. (2009). Sample surveys with
294. sensitive questions: a non-randomized
295. American Statistician, 63, 9-16.
296. response approach.
297. Warner, S.L. (1971). The linear randomized response model. Journal of
298. the American Statistical Association, 366, 884-888.
299. Tian, G.-L., Tan, M., and Ng, K.W. (2007). An exact non-iterative
300. sampling procedure for discrete missing data problems. Statistica
301. Neerlandica, 61, 232-242.
302. Tian, G.-L., Yu, J.W., Tang, M.L., Geng, Z. (2007). A new nonrandomized
303. model for analyzing sensitive questions with binary outcomes.
304. Statistics in Medicine, 26, 4238-4252.
305. Yu, J.-W., Tian, G.-L., Tang, M.-L. (2008). Two new models for survey
306. sampling with sensitive characteristics: design and Analysis.
307. Metrika, 67, 251-263