Multi-trait multi environment analysis for stability in MABC lines of Chickpea (Cicer arietinum)

Abstract views: 210 / PDF downloads: 174


  • J JORBEN PhD scholar
  • APOORVA RAO Research Scholar
  • C BHARADWAJ Principal Scientist
  • S D NITESH PhD scholar
  • NEHA TIWARI Associate Scientist
  • TAPAN KUMAR Associate Scientist
  • D R SAXENA scientist
  • M YASIN scientist
  • P L SONTAKKE Principal scientist
  • JAGDISH E JAHAGIRDAR Principal scientist
  • V S HEGDE Principal scientist


MABC, Fusarium wilt, MTSI, GGE


Fusarium wilt (Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. ciceris) is a major disease that can cause up to 90% yield loss in Chickpea (Cicer arietinum L.). The presence of 8 physiological races of Foc (0, 1A, 1B/C, 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6) makes it a complex task in the development of disease-resistant cultivar. Thus, Pyramiding of Foc races 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 was undertaken using WR 315 as donor and Pusa 372 as recurrent parent through Marker assisted backcross (MABC) breeding approach. A total of 20 genotypes, including 17 MABC derived lines of Pusa 372 × WR 315, susceptible parent (Pusa 372), resistant check (WR 315) and national check (JG 16) were used. Multi-location testing of advanced MABC lines at 4 different regions (Amla, Badnapur, Sehore, IARI-New Delhi) was carried out using randomised block design (RBD) in two replications during 2020–21 winter (rabi) season. Usually, multi environment testing is performed involving a single trait, which provides lower reliability in selection of lines, compared to multi-trait analysis. The present study identifies highly stable Fusarium wilt resistant lines with higher yield advantage using MTSI (Multi trait stability index) and GGE (Genotype main effect and genotype × environment interaction) biplot methodology. From GGE biplot analyses the PC1 explains 84.97% and PC2 explains 8.96% of variability. MTSI results revealed that genotype (G) 1, 4 and 3 were stable for the multiple characters studied. But, based on GGE-mean stability value G 11, 12 and 3 were identified for higher yield and better stability values. Based on MTSI and GGE, G 3 may be considered as a stable line for multiple traits including yield superiority.


Download data is not yet available.

Author Biographies

  • J JORBEN, PhD scholar

    Division of Genetics,ICAR-IARI,New Delhi-12

  • APOORVA RAO, Research Scholar
    Division of Genetics,ICAR-IARI,New Delhi-12
  • C BHARADWAJ, Principal Scientist
    Division of Genetics,ICAR-IARI,New Delhi-12
  • S D NITESH, PhD scholar

    Department of Plant Breeding & Genetics, CSAUAT, Kanpur, UP.

  • NEHA TIWARI, Associate Scientist

    ICARDA-Food Legume Research Platform, Amlah, Sehore, MP, India, 466113

  • TAPAN KUMAR, Associate Scientist

    ICARDA-Food Legume Research Platform, Amlah, Sehore, MP, India, 466113

  • D R SAXENA, scientist

    RAK College of Agriculture, RVSKVV,Sehore, MP, India, 466001

  • M YASIN, scientist

    RAK College of Agriculture, RVSKVV,Sehore, MP, India, 466001

  • P L SONTAKKE, Principal scientist

    Agricultural Research Station, Badnapur, Maharashtra

  • JAGDISH E JAHAGIRDAR, Principal scientist

    Agricultural Research Station, Badnapur, Maharashtra

  • V S HEGDE, Principal scientist

    Division of Genetics,ICAR-IARI,New Delhi-12


Allard R W and Bradshaw A D. 1964. Implications of genotype × environmental interactions in applied plant breeding. Crop science 4(5): 503–08. DOI:

Baxevanos D, Goulas C, Rossi J and Braojos E. 2008. Separation of cotton cultivar testing sites based on representativeness and discriminating ability using GGE biplots. Agronomy Journal 100(5): 1230–36. DOI:

Benakanahalli N K, Sridhara S, Ramesh N, Olivoto T, Sreekantappa G, Tamam N, Abdelbacki A M M, Elansary H O and Abdelmohsen S A. 2021. A Framework for Identification of Stable Genotypes Based on MTSI and MGDII Indexes: An Example in Guar (Cymopsis tetragonoloba L.). Agronomy Journal 11(6): 1221. DOI:

Bharadwaj C, Srivastava R, Chauhan S K, Satyavathi C T, Kumar J, Faruqui A, Yadav S, Rizvi A H and Kumar T. 2011. Molecular diversity and phylogeny in geographical collection of chickpea (Cicer sp.) accessions. Journal of Genetics 90: 94–100 DOI:

Blanche S B and Myers G O. 2006. Identifying discriminating locations for cultivar selection in Louisiana. Crop Science 46(2): 946–49. DOI:

Bornhofen E, Todeschini M H, Stoco M G, Madureira A , Marchioro V S, Storck L and Benin G. 2018. Wheat yield improvements in Brazil: Roles of genetics and environment. Crop Science 58(1): 1–12. DOI:

Comstock R E and Moll R H. 1963. Genotype-environmentinteractions. Statistical Genetics and Plant Breeding, pp. 164–196. Hanson W D, Robinson H F (Eds). National Academy of Sciences–National Research Council Publication, Washington, DC, USA

Dehghani H, Ebadi A and Yousefi A 2006. Biplot analysis of genotype by environment interaction for barley yield in Iran. Agronomy Journal 98(2): 388–93. DOI:

Dixit G P, Srivastava A K and Singh N P 2019. Marching towards self-sufficiency in chickpea. Current Science 116(2): 239–42. DOI:

Gauch H G and Zobel R 1996. Genotype-by-Environment Interaction. Chemical Rubber Company press, Boca Raton, Florida. DOI:

Harish D, Bharadwaj C, Tapan Kumar, Patil B S, Madan Pal, Hegde V S and Ashutosh Sarker. 2020. Identification of stable drought tolerant landraces of chickpea (Cicer arietinum) under multiple environments. Indian Journal of Agricultural Sciences 90(8): 1575–81.

Haware M P and Nene Y L 1982. Races of Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. ciceri. Plant disease 66(9): 809–10. DOI:

Lakew T, Tariku S, Alem T and Bitew M. 2014. Agronomic performances and stability analysis of upland rice genotypes in North West Ethiopia. International Journal of Scientific and Research Publications 4(4): 1–9.

Mohammadi R and Amri A. 2012. Analysis of genotype × environment interaction in rainfed durum wheat of Iran using GGE-biplot and non-parametric methods. Canadian Journal of Plant Science 92(4): 757–70. DOI:

Nitesh S D, ParashuramPatroti and Shilpa Parashuram. 2021. TraitStasts: Statistical Data Analysis for Randomized Block Design Experiments. R Package version 1.0.1.

Olivoto T and Lucio A D C. 2020. Metan: An R package for multi environment trial analysis. Methods in Ecology and Evolution 11(6): 783–89. DOI:

Olivoto T, Lucio A D, da Silva J A, Marchioro V S, de Souza V Q and Jost E. 2019. Mean performance and stability in multi environment trials I: Combining features of AMMI and BLUP techniques. Agronomy Journal 111(6): 2949–60. DOI:

Sharma M, Ghosh R, Tarafdar A, Rathore A, Chobe D R, Kumar A V, Gaur P M, Samineni S, Gupta Om, Singh N P, Saxena D R, Sanifulla M, Pithia M S , Ghante P H, Deyanand M, Mahalinga, Upadhyay J B and Harer P N. 2019. Exploring the genetic cipher of chickpea (Cicer arietinum L.) through identification and multi-environment validation of resistant sources against Fusarium wilt (Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. ciceris). Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 3: 78. DOI:

Yan W and Kang M S. 2002. GGE Biplot Analysis: A Graphical Tool for Breeders, Geneticists, and Agronomists. Chemical Rubber Company press. Boca Raton, Florida. DOI:

Yan W. 2010. Optimal use of biplots in analysis of multi-location variety test data. Acta Agronomica Sinica 36(11): 1805–19.

Zuffo A M, Steiner F, Aguilera J G, Teodoro P E, Teodoro L P R and Busch A. 2020. Multi trait stability index: A tool for simultaneous selection of soya bean genotypes in drought and saline stress. Journal of Agronomy and Crop Science 206(6): 815–22. DOI:









How to Cite

JORBEN, J., RAO, A., BHARADWAJ, C., NITESH, S. D., TIWARI, N., KUMAR, T., SAXENA, D. R., YASIN, M., SONTAKKE, P. L., JAHAGIRDAR, J. E., & HEGDE, V. S. (2022). Multi-trait multi environment analysis for stability in MABC lines of Chickpea (Cicer arietinum). The Indian Journal of Agricultural Sciences, 92(8), 1005-1009.