Prevalence and determinants of false pregnancy diagnosis in buffaloes: Field evidence from Andhra Pradesh, India

SRUTHI P; GUNJAN  BHANDARI; UDITA  CHAUDHARY; SANJIT  MAITI; SUDARSHAN  KUMAR; SUNEEL K  ONTERU

doi:10.56093/ijans.v95i6.167525

Authors

SRUTHI P ICAR – National Dairy Research Institute, Karnal 132 001, Haryana
GUNJAN BHANDARI ICAR – National Dairy Research Institute, Karnal 132 001, Haryana
UDITA CHAUDHARY ICAR – National Dairy Research Institute, Karnal 132 001, Haryana
SANJIT MAITI ICAR – National Dairy Research Institute, Karnal 132 001, Haryana
SUDARSHAN KUMAR ICAR – National Dairy Research Institute, Karnal 132 001, Haryana
SUNEEL K ONTERU ICAR – National Dairy Research Institute, Karnal 132 001, Haryana

https://doi.org/10.56093/ijans.v95i6.167525

Keywords:

Buffaloes, False diagnosis, Pregnancy diagnosis, Rectal palpation, Visual observation

Abstract

Accurate and timely pregnancy diagnosis is vital for efficient reproductive management and economic sustainability in buffalo husbandry. This study examines prevalence and determinants of false pregnancy diagnosis in buffaloes under field conditions across four major buffalo–rearing districts of Andhra Pradesh: Guntur, Prakasam, Krishna and Nellore. A multistage random sampling method yielded data from 240 dairy farmers and 415 buffaloes, capturing information on visual observation of estrus for pregnancy diagnosis (VOB) at 21±3–days intervals and rectal palpation (RP) conducted 60–120 days post-AI. The diagnostic accuracy of both methods was evaluated for sensitivity, specificity, predictive values and overall accuracy. VOB, though widely used, showed high sensitivity but low specificity, resulting in a considerable rate of false positives. In contrast, RP demonstrated significantly higher accuracy and reliability. Binary logistic regression was employed to identify factors influencing false diagnosis. For VOB, increased farmer experience and awareness significantly reduced false diagnosis risk, while larger herd sizes, poor body condition, reproductive disorders and high ambient temperatures elevated the risk. For RP, higher animal parity reduced false diagnosis odds, whereas poor body condition and specific seasonal contexts slightly compromised accuracy.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Abdullah M, Mohanty T K, Kumaresan A, Mohanty A K, Madkar A R, Baithalu R K and Bhakat M. 2014. Early pregnancy diagnosis in dairy cattle: Economic importance and accuracy of ultrasonography. Advances in Animal and Veterinary Sciences 2(8): 464–67.

Balhara A K, Gupta M, Singh S, Mohanty A K and Singh I. 2013. Early pregnancy diagnosis in bovines: current status and future directions. The Scientific World Journal 2013: 958540

Banuvalli N, Harisha M, Gururaj P M, Umesh B U, Veeranna Gowda B G and Gopala G T. 2015. Heat (estrus) detection techniques in dairy farms- A review. Theriogenology Insight 5(2): 125–33.

Baratloo A, Hosseini M, Negida A and Ashal G E. 2015. Part 1: Simple definition and calculation of accuracy, sensitivity and specificity. Spring 3(2): 48–49.

Caton J S, Crouse M S, McLean K J, Dahlen C R, Ward K A, Cushman R A, Grazul-Bilska A T, Neville B W, Borowicz P P and Reynolds L P. 2020. Maternal periconceptual nutrition, early pregnancy, and developmental outcomes in beef cattle. Journal of Animal Sciences 98(12): 358.

De Rensis F, Garcia-Ispierto I, Lopez-Gatius F and Techakumphu M. 2019. Factors affecting the success of timed artificial insemination programs in dairy cattle. Theriogenology 137: 1–7.

Diskin M G. 2008. Heat Watch: a telemetric system for heat detection in cattle. Veterinary Quarterly 30: 37–48.

Ghuman S and Singh J. 2009. A benchmark study on reproductive management assessment of dairy animals under rural smallholder conditions. The Internet Journal of Veterinary Medicine 8(1): 73594811.

Hanzen C H, Pieterse M, Scenczi O and Drost M. 2000. Relative accuracy of the identification of ovarian structures in the cow by ultrasonography and palpation per rectum. The Veterinary Journal 159: 161–70

Ingawale M V, Bakshi S A, Birade H S, Chinchkar S R and Gulavane S U. 2014. Early detection of pregnancy using ultrasonography in buffaloes. Buffalo Bulletin 31(4): 202–08. Jaśkowski J M, Kaczmarowski M, Kulus J, Jaśkowski B M, Herudzińska M and Gehrke M. 2019. Rectal palpation for pregnancy in cows: A relic or an alternative to modern diagnostic methods. Medycyna waterynaryjna 75(5): 259–64.

Kumar B, Sahoo A K, Ray P K, Chandran P C, Taraphder S, Das A K, Batabyal S and Dayal, S. 2019. Evaluation of environmental heat stress on physical and hormonal parameters in Murrah buffalo. Journal of Animal Health and Production 7(1): 21–24.

Kumar P C, Chatrapathy K, Manjula V and Thangadurai N. 2021. A novel technique for early pregnancy detection of dairy cattle. International Journal of Innovative Science, Engineering & Technology 8(2): 2348–7968.

Lech M, Wilkowska M, Kwaśniewicz A, Graczyk S, Grzeczka A, Kulus J, Gehrke M., Kolomak I and Jaśkowski J M. 2022. Progress in acquiring skills in cattle rectal examination by veterinary students consulting their acquired experience and professional motivation. Medycyna Weterynaryjna 78(08): 6683–22.

Lopez H, Satter L D and Wiltbank M C. 2004. Relation between level of milk production and estrus behavior of lactating dairy cow. Animal Reproduction Science 81: 209–23.

NDDB. 2023. National Dairy Development Board. Retrieved from https://www.nddb.coop/services/animalbreeding/ animalreproduction/ai#:~:text=About%2080%20million%20 inseminations%20are,the%20quality%20of%20AI%20 services

Orihuela A. 2000. Some factors affecting the behavioural manifestation of oestrus in cattle: A review. Applied Animal Behaviour Science 70(1): 1–16.

Pannu S P, Kumar T, Pruthi C and Mehra M. 2022. Summer anestrus and its management in buffaloes. The Pharma Innovation Journal 11(7): 2400–02.

Patel M D, Parmar S C, Patel A S, Makwana P P, Rajput M B, Patel J H and Patel AG. 2016. Early pregnancy diagnosis in dairy animals. International Journal of Agriculture Sciences 8(11):1134–36.

Team Pashudhan Praharee. 2023. Methods of pregnancy diagnosis in domestic animals: mini review of recent advances & ancient technique. Pashudhan Prahareede.

Trevethan R. 2017. Sensitivity, specificity, and predictive values: foundations, pliabilities, and pitfalls in research and practice. Frontiers in Public Health 5: 307.

Walker S L, Smith R F, Routly J E, Jones D N, Morris M J and Dobson H. 2008. Lameness, activity time–budgets and estrus expression in dairy cattle. Journal of Dairy Science 91: 4552– 59.

Yadav R, Tripathi H, Kumar P and Ramesh N. 2019. Assessing the economic losses to buffalo owners due to late diagnosis of pregnancy in their milch buffaloes. Asian Journal of Agricultural Extension, Economics & Sociology 33(4):1–6.